Home · Maps · About

Home > OTChat

[ Post a New Response | Return to the Index ]

(775804)

view threaded

Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by WillD on Wed May 4 21:20:24 2011

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
...and now the pieces of its tail are probably on the way to China.

Can we just let India buy/build JSFs for their MCRA fighter program and have at Pakistan now? 'Allies' my ass.

But anyway, the black helicopter conspiracy nuts may have some cause for their paranoia. It certainly could explain why the USAF's CSAR-X program was such a nightmare for Sikorsky, Boeing, and LockMart. Maybe we didn't really push hard on a new rescue/SOC helo to replace the HH-60s because we had this stealth helicopter in some sort of prototype or production footing. Or, if we have a stealth helo for the dangerous work, then the larger payload of something like the HH-47 makes more sense, even though one of the stated goals of the CSAR-X program was to begin working to combine the rescue and special ops helicopters into one airframe.

From ABC News

Top Secret Stealth Helicopter Program Revealed in Osama Bin Laden Raid

By BRIAN ROSS (@brianross) , RHONDA SCHWARTZ, LEE FERRAN and AVNI PATEL
May 4, 2011
Before an elite team of U.S. Navy SEALs executed a daring raid that took down Osama bin Laden, the commandos were able to silently sneak up on their elusive target thanks to what aviation analysts said were top secret, never-before-seen stealth-modified helicopters.

In the course of the operation that cost the al Qaeda leader his life, one of the two Blackhawk helicopters that carried the SEALs into bin Laden's Pakistani compound grazed one of the compound's wall and was forced to make a hard landing. With the chopper inoperable, at the end of the mission the SEALs destroyed it with explosives.

But photos of what survived the explosion -- the tail section of the craft with curious modifications -- has sent military analysts buzzing about a stealth helicopter program that was only rumored to exist. From a modified tail boom to a noise reducing covering on the rear rotors and a special high-tech material similar to that used in stealth fighters, former Department of Defense official and vice president of the Lexington Institute Dan Goure said the bird is like nothing he's ever seen before.

"This is a first," he said. "You wouldn't know that it was coming right at you. And that's what's important, because these are coming in fast and low, and if they aren't sounding like they're coming right at you, you might not even react until it's too late... That was clearly part of the success."

In addition to the noise-reducing modifications, a former special operations aviator told The Army Times the general shape of what was left of the craft -- the harsh angles and flat surfaces more common to stealth jets -- was further evidence it was a modified variant of the Blackhawk.

A senior Pentagon official told ABC News the Defense Department would "absolutely not" comment on anything relating to the destroyed bird.

The U.S. has attempted to use stealth helicopters before. In the mid-90s, the Army developed several prototypes of the Comanche helicopter, a reconnaissance helicopter that was at the time a revolutionary step in stealth technology. But in 2004 the Department of Defense scrapped the program and promised to used technology developed for the Comanche on other crafts.

Since, the government has been working to silence the Army's Blackhawk helicopters but an official program for the stealth choppers was never publicized. The wreckage, Sweetman said, is the first the public has ever seen of an operational stealth-modified helicopter.

Goure said he believes the stealthy Blackhawks have been in use for years without the public's knowledge.

"We probably have been running hundreds of missions with these helicopters over the last half dozen years, and the fact is, they've all been successful -- or at least the helicopters have all come back," he said.

But now that one went down and photographs emerged of large sections being taken from the crash site under a tarp, former White House counterterrorism advisor and ABC News consultant Richard Clarke said U.S. officials may have reason to worry about where those parts end up.

"There are probably people in the Pentagon tonight who are very concerned that pieces of the helicopter may be, even now, on their way to China, because we know that China is trying to make stealth aircraft," he said. The Chinese military is known to have a close relationship with the Pakistani military.
Photos from elsewhere on the internet:


From Army Times, which makes no mention of connection with Chinese. IMHO that image makes it look a bit like the AH-64's X shaped rotor with a disc covering the tail rotor hub.



The Daily Mail has an interesting take on the subject. The experts they talked to indicate that the tail roter does not appear to be from an H-60 type helo. If the raid indeed launched from Jalalabad in Afghanistan, then a larger helicopter, perhaps in the H-92, or even H-53 families would be a likely candidate for the basic airframe of the stealthy helicopter. Then again, it is a helicopter and forward support using tankers and forward area replenishment points are things the USSOCOM is extremely good at.

And finally:



Some speculation from Wired and Defense Tech as to what the helo may have looked like. From the fully stealthed H-60 variant seen in the ABC news piece, to the Chinese speculation which appears to be a fairly standard MH-60M with a tail rotor that looks optimized for considerably quieter operation:



Post a New Response

(775823)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by Dan Lawrence on Wed May 4 21:34:10 2011, in response to Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by WillD on Wed May 4 21:20:24 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Old news. Every wire service in the world carried this story. In virtually every newspaper it was reported in great detail.

Post a New Response

(775824)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by Fred G on Wed May 4 21:36:24 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by Dan Lawrence on Wed May 4 21:34:10 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Well jeez Dan, OTCHat isn't out to scoop anyone, we just post 'em and talk about 'em.

your pal,
Fred

Post a New Response

(775835)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by WillD on Wed May 4 21:47:55 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by Dan Lawrence on Wed May 4 21:34:10 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Yes I am well aware. But I hadn't seen it posted here as yet. And it most certainly was not reported 'in great detail' in any newspaper, because virtually every official story on the matter runs into a stone wall from the DoD on the matter. I figured it'd do me some good to organize my thoughts regarding some of the internet speculation while summarizing some of the theories developed regarding the mysterious tail left behind in Abbottabad. Do you object to my doing this? Furthermore, do you have anything of substance to add to this discussion or are you just going to claim 'the newspapers did it'?

IMHO this is a much bigger deal than the use of F-117s in Panama. There we had a project which may have started out in the public eye, but which quickly became black, and then did a rather poor job of maintaining absolute operational surprise. After all, Testors and others kept the F-19 Stealth Fighter rumor alive through the 1980s, even if they were quite wide of the actual aircraft's designator and aesthetics. But there was virtually no indication that the DoD was pursuing any sort of significant upgrade to their special ops helos until Sunday. We may have had the RAH-66, but it was canceled after what sounded like a series of almost impossible technical hurdles were reached. It would appear we've either found solutions to those hurdles, or developed some workaround such that we can fly helicopters into one of the best air defense networks you can buy from the French, Chinese, and US without detection.

Post a New Response

(775838)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by SelkirkTMO on Wed May 4 21:48:42 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by WillD on Wed May 4 21:47:55 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
ABC claimed it was an "exclusive" earlier, so I'd say there's proff. :)

Post a New Response

(776141)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by Dan Lawrence on Thu May 5 09:57:27 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by Fred G on Wed May 4 21:36:24 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Fred, sometimes I have to wash my hands after an OTChat session. It's like stuffing the trash bags in the can every Tuesday night. :-)

Post a New Response

(776158)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by Terrapin Station on Thu May 5 10:37:28 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by Dan Lawrence on Wed May 4 21:34:10 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Incorrect, Dan Lawrence. Why are you practically always wrong????

Post a New Response

(776265)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by SelkirkTMO on Thu May 5 16:19:29 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by Terrapin Station on Thu May 5 10:37:28 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
Check your postage meter

Post a New Response

(776279)

view threaded

Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack...

Posted by RockParkMan on Thu May 5 16:46:40 2011, in response to Re: Stealth Helicopter destroyed in OBL attack..., posted by WillD on Wed May 4 21:47:55 2011.

edf40wrjww2msgDetailOT:detailStr
fiogf49gjkf0d
"After all, Testors and others kept the F-19 Stealth Fighter rumor alive through the 1980s, even if they were quite wide of the actual aircraft's designator and aesthetics."

http://www.fantastic-plastic.com/TESTORS%20F-19%20STEALTH%20PAGE.htm

Looks like Testors got their design inspiration from the SR-71.

Post a New Response


[ Return to the Message Index ]