Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) (47825)	Home · Maps · About
Home > The Reef

[ Read Responses | Post a New Response | Return to the Index ]
[ First in Thread | Next in Thread ]

view flat

Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train)

Posted by Train Dude on Tue Feb 16 15:07:34 2010, in response to Re: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train, posted by Olog-hai on Tue Feb 16 14:19:48 2010. This debate is simply going around in circles. We're mixing apples & oranges or consequences and punishment. Assume instead of painting a train, the criminal was robbing a bank. Also assume instead of losing his leg to a subway train wheel, he lost it to a police officer's gun. The bottom line is that the loss of the leg was a consequence of the criminal behavior. We would fully expect that the criminal justice system would not forgive the bank robber solely because of the loss of the leg. It would still expect that some punishment is due.

Responses

•  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Olog-hai - Tue Feb 16 15:14:15 2010
•  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - arnine - Tue Feb 16 15:39:24 2010
•  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Mr Volt - Tue Feb 16 15:43:30 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - rbseabeach - Tue Feb 16 15:51:45 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Railman718 - Tue Feb 16 16:03:06 2010
      •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Railman718 - Tue Feb 16 16:04:08 2010
      •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - rbseabeach - Tue Feb 16 16:07:21 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Olog-hai - Tue Feb 16 16:09:06 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - jabrams - Tue Feb 16 16:32:07 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Railman718 - Tue Feb 16 16:45:52 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Broadway Lion - Tue Feb 16 16:53:07 2010
•  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Stephen Bauman - Tue Feb 16 19:35:49 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Train Dude - Tue Feb 16 20:17:26 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Railman718 - Tue Feb 16 20:23:50 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - trainsarefun - Tue Feb 16 20:54:24 2010
      •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Train Dude - Tue Feb 16 21:04:18 2010
        •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Broadway Lion - Tue Feb 16 22:59:01 2010
          •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Stephen Bauman - Tue Feb 16 23:26:18 2010
          •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Nilet - Wed Feb 17 07:31:34 2010
•  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Nilet - Wed Feb 17 07:55:57 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Mr Volt - Wed Feb 17 08:08:01 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Railman718 - Wed Feb 17 08:11:39 2010
  •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Olog-hai - Wed Feb 17 09:24:14 2010
    •  Re: Consequences & Punishment (was: 'Graffiti Teen' Hit By Subway Train) - Nilet - Wed Feb 17 11:28:10 2010

 Thread is locked Responses disabled